Many, many moons ago, when I was in college a debate stirred.
Mind you, I went to a very small, conservative Christian college. Debates didn’t happen. Well. Not officially. Because to debate might open you up to the possiblities of the Other Side. It was easier, for most of my co-ed colleagues, to just be Right. Sometimes I picked arguments just to see what would happen. In my freshman year I made the fatal error of assuming that one could debate a topic from either side. Turns out, in that bubble, you couldn’t ever play the devil’s advocate. For a semester an entire class shifted their seats away from me on a daily basis because I had tried, in a matter of debating, to defend a side of a dictator. It didn’t matter that I personally did not agree with the dictator in question– it only mattered that I was open to seeing things from his point of view. I learned my lesson and stayed as quiet as possible from then on. Landing into trouble, in this new manner of keeping, only two or three times a week instead of daily.
Anyhoo. I bring this up because, around that time there was a quasi-debate going about the music in churches. In those days a lot of evangelical churches were switching over to “contemporary” formats and tossing out the hymnals full of the old standards. Apparently, the consensus among my peers at that time was that this was a good thing. They prattled off the arguments about churches having to be relevant and Now!-ish. That no young person could really relate to the old lyrics and tunes of the old hymns.
At the time I thought they were all full of… well. I wasn’t supposed to use that word.
I like old hymns. I like the old gospel songs. For me there was a mystical magic in the words. There still is. I remember arguing once with a dear one about the Words in Hymns That Nobody Really Understands. Those were the words I liked best. My Mom helped me with a few of them. I distinctly remember when the word “diadem” as in “Bring forth the royal dia-dem…” caught my 7 or 8 year old ear. I knew what the cherubin were but the seraphim at Christmas time involved a trip to the dictionary in the back of my Dad’s study Bible. There are still hymns that make me smile at the sound of their opening bars because I know they are chocked full of interesting phrases.
Okay, it’s true. There are “contemporary” songs that have been written to ease the learning curve. And it’s true that noone phrases things exactly as they do in the hymnals… I haven’t ever “survey”-ed anything, or had my soul “attendeth,” or brought up the sum of my trangressions in any recent conversations.
But the old stuff works for me.
Yesterday, in the newspaper, there was an article about the reemergence of the old music in churches today. That even the big, scary, BigBox, mall churches that were built to the technobeats of contemporary worship are revisiting the “classics” because the young people have sought them out.
HAH! (It takes me years sometimes to win a debate. Let me savor this moment. Albeit a lonely, lonely moment.)
Besides. When my best pal’s Grandmother died years ago… when we were both long old enough to know better, we burst into giggles at the funeral because, I pointed out, the hymnist wasn’t really “alone” In the Garden– I was there, too. Remember? “As I tarry there?” He just got the spelling wrong.
I have an open mind. I’ll let it slide.